Re: Rating Shop #1: Map Rating Thread

[Forgotten]

OK, let me make an announcement.
--ANNOUNCEMENT--
OK, from now on, if anyone who is rating a map doesn't use the form opn the first post, will receive warning points, no ifs, ands, or buts about it. That is all.

-Ruka

[God of War]

Hey Ruka, I was just wondering, can I make a response thats kinda like that? It looks like this:

Rating:
Tile Errors:
Overall Errors:
Suggestions:

[Forgotten]

No you may not.

[windwos]

Here's my map from my hack.
P.S. I know its square but its supposed to be like that




Edited By Sandro.

[.Iramet]

Rating-1.5/10 Sorry
Errors-there are not to many tile errors except for that strange rock formation thingy...
Suggestions-well A different pallete may be a good idea it just looks so boring all blue.
Comments-Well you definetely could have tried harder with the actual mapping.

[windwos]

heres another map of mine and the til error in the pokemon center cant be fixed (by Me) and it came like that

[.Iramet]

Hey I decided to use netI's tiles from his rombase...so tell me what you think peoples.

[windwos]

Hey I decided to use netI's tiles from his rombase...so tell me what you think peoples.

Rating: 9/10
Errors: I really dont see any
Suggestions: I think every thing is great exept that it kinda looks boring I think if you added some differnt kind of trees and got rid of some rocks it would be to me a 10/10
Comments:I like your map alot and your a realy good mapper

[.Iramet]

heres another map of mine and the til error in the pokemon center cant be fixed (by Me) and it came like that[img][img=https://2img.net/r/ihimizer/img182/5748/mapjr7.th.png][/img]

Rating-5.7/10
Errors-no tile errors
Suggestions-well you need to block the edges because you can easily reach the border blocks and people shouldn't be able to do that,also the map is very sporradic with all the bushes and rocks lined up in that way.the path should reach in front of the houses and centers.overall a very poorly done map
Comments-don't take anything I said the wrong way please,When I began mapping that is exactly how my maps used to look.So don't feel like you are horrible or anything you will definetely excel.

Also here is an updated version of my previous map blocking the areas were you could get to the border

[Platinum Lucario]

Rating-5.7/10
Errors-no tile errors
Suggestions-well you need to block the edges because you can easily reach the border blocks and people shouldn't be able to do that,also the map is very sporradic with all the bushes and rocks lined up in that way.the path should reach in front of the houses and centers.overall a very poorly done map
Comments-don't take anything I said the wrong way please,When I began mapping that is exactly how my maps used to look.So don't feel like you are horrible or anything you will definetely excel.

Also here is an updated version of my previous map blocking the areas were you could get to the border

Rating: 2.3/10.0
Errors: On the left hand side, there should be a second row of a platform. Because yours is only one. D: And also the platform on the other side is cut off and goes into the forest.
Suggestions: Try fixing the left hand side so that there is a second row of a platform, so that tile error can be fixed. And make a platform on the other side as well.
Comments: Apart from the tile error, this map is pretty good. If you fixed those tile errors I would have given you a higher score.

That should be all for now, good luck with the mapping.

[.Iramet]

ya thanks for the rating silver.....I was hoping nobody would notice that,you have a very good eye for detail i'll fix it.

[.:Sandro:.]

Well its been a while... here is a map i made. This is the original one:


Then it was edited:

The map was edited by Synyster_Zeikku.

[.Iramet]

I will only rate the second I'm short on time.
rating-8.3/10
errors-I don't really see any
suggestions-Well I like the map but the lake should be a different shape it looks really awkward like that
comments-overall a great map

[thededkid]

wow.. all of these maps are really good....mabie i will be that good someday!

[.Iramet]

Here is one of my maps.

Please rate it.
^_^

[Platinum Lucario]

Here is one of my maps.

Please rate it.
^_^

It looks ok, but I think it might need a bit of improving, let's see how things go. :\

Tile Errors: There is one in the south-eastern part of the map, near the grass. I can't see anymore, so I guess that's about it.

Suggestions: The map looks ok, but the house there should be replaced with one of the houses from a town. And there is a tile error you need to fix. And there's a sign in front of a door?!? That should be put somewhere else. :\

Comments: The map does look ok, but it still needs a lot of fixing to do.

Rating: This map should have a lot of things that need to be done, so I'd give it a 3.8/10.0.

Good luck on the mapping, I know you can fix the problems.

[.:Sandro:.]

OK a map to be rated.
Name:N/A
Map Of: Fire Red
Map Preview:


Please Rate^^

[Forgotten]

From Now on, if the map is big, just make a link to it to view, because the posts won't let anything go past the border!

@sandro:
Rating: 7/10~
Errors: No tile errors
Suggestions: Take out the wild pkmn grass and fill in empty spots.
Comments: The shape, and the map overall is good.

[Sponsored content]